The first models were expensive and inefficient, spinning fast and low. “When we start to sell to more builders, we can take in a lot more of them. Tens of thousands of aging blades are coming down from steel towers around the world and most have nowhere to go but landfills. In the meantime, Bratvold and his co-workers have set aside about a half dozen blades and in coming months, they’ll experiment with methods to squeeze them into smaller footprints. The wind turbine blades are a toxic amalgam of unique composites, fiberglass, epoxy, polyvinyl chloride foam, polyethylene terephthalate foam, balsa wood, and polyurethane coatings. Until large-scale recycling is widely available, landfills must accommodate defunct blades. Workers are experimenting with methods to fit more blades in their graves. With this week's announcement, GE Renewable Energy becomes the latest major company connected to the wind energy sector to attempt to reduce its environmental footprint. Cappadona went on to state that this would ultimately result in "greener cement that can be used for a variety of products." Up a gentle northern slope, a shooting club boasts of cowboy-action pistol ranges. GE Renewable Energy and Veolia North America (VNA) have signed a "multi-year agreement" to recycle blades removed from onshore wind turbines in the United States. All Rights Reserved. Read More > Changing the world through the power of wind Each day we work to change the world through the power of wind, creating a cleaner, greener future for everyone on our shared home, earth. The boom-bust oil town was founded at the turn of the 19th century. This happens through the turning of large fiberglass blades, which then spin a generator to produce electricity. Blades are made from composite materials, which means they can be difficult to recycle. Making a wind turbine blade is quite a labor-intensive process. Their steel tubes rose 260 feet and sported swooping fiberglass blades. Turbine blades can be bigger than the wing of a Boeing 747, and many of them end up in landfills once they’re removed from service. "By adding wind turbine blades — which are primarily made of fiberglass — to replace raw materials for cement manufacturing, we are reducing the amount of … “Innovation is born from collaboration and we look forward to working together to advance wind turbine blade recycling.” "zero-waste" wind turbines by the year 2040. research paper from the University of Cambridge. Wind power is carbon-free, and about 85% of turbine components, including steel, copper wire, electronics and gearing, can be recycled or reused. MFG Wind has resourced each facet to ensure customer satisfaction for the life of each blade. Down the road, the sprawling landfill bustles and a dozen wind turbines spin gently on the horizon. Wind turbines have increased in size and quantity to meet clean energy capacity demands Modern wind power converts the kinetic (movement) energy from wind into mechanical energy. Recommended to you based on your activity and what's popular • Feedback They are ecologically quite sound. It disposes all the blades it receives, with as many as 10 trucks per day hauling them to the company’s Lake Mills landfill. ©2020 Bloomberg L.P. “Wind turbine blades at the end of their operational life are landfill-safe, unlike the waste from some other energy sources, and represent a small fraction of overall U.S. municipal solid waste,” according to an emailed statement from the group. “We want to make it a sustainable business. The company is currently scaling up and plans to boost production capacity by the end of this year. At the time, the Aarhaus-headquartered firm sought to highlight the issue of waste related to turbine blades by citing a 2017 research paper from the University of Cambridge. GFS says it’s the first U.S.-based company to commercially recycle fiberglass wind turbine blades. The principle design of commercial turbines today are horizontal axis wind turbines consisting of a rotor with three fiberglass blades attached to a hub, which is itself attached to a central piece (the nacelle) that is mounted on a steel tower. “They see these wind turbines as something that’s hurting coal and oil.”. Ninety percent of a turbine's parts can be recycled or sold, according to Van Vleet, but the blades, made of a tough but pliable mix of resin and fiberglass … Stay Connected It is for this reason, among others, that glass and carbon fibres are most commonly used in the fabrication of wind turbine blades today. The Invenergy Judith Gap wind farm in central Montana, uses 90 wind turbines from GE. As explained by Scientific American, conventional blades are made by materials layered on top of each other. FOCUSED. This is because the blades are made from composite materials which are difficult to recycle, which means that many end up as landfill when their service life ends. A worker walks past wind turbine blades awaiting transport in Fort Madison, Iowa. Referencing analysis carried out by Quantis U.S., GE Renewable Energy said blade recycling would allow for a "27% net reduction in CO2 emissions from cement production." The wind energy industry represents one of the fastest growing application sectors of composites, where reinforcement fibers, such as fiberglass or carbon fibers, a plastic polymer, such as polyester or epoxy, and a core material are used to build strong and compliant rotor blades . Fragments of wind turbine blades await burial at the Casper Regional Landfill in Wyoming. For water consumption, this would see a net drop of 13%. FREE . A decade later, General Electric Co. made its 1.5 megawatt model—enough to supply 1,200 homes in a stiff breeze—an industry standard. But the fiberglass blades remain difficult to dispose of. They’ve tried bunkers, berms and even crushing them with the bulldozer, but the tracks kept slipping off the smooth blades. Wind power is carbon-free and about 85% of turbine components, including steel, copper wire, electronics and gearing can be recycled or reused. According to the paper, waste produced by wind turbine blades could hit an estimated 43.4 million metric tons by the year 2050. “The chemical industry plays a decisive role in the transition to a circular economy by investing in the research and development of new materials, which make wind turbine blades more reliable, affordable and recyclable,” says CEFIC Director General, Marco Mensink. Wind energy is one of the cheapest ways to reach that goal. The issue of what to do with wind turbine blades when they're no longer needed creates a number of challenges. The municipal landfill in Casper, Wyoming, is the final resting place of 870 blades whose days making renewable energy have come to end. Breaking News. Incredible photos have revealed the final resting place of massive wind turbine blades that cannot be recycled, and are instead heaped up in piles in landfills. Veolia’s North American unit will shred the fiberglass blades at a site in Missouri and convert them into a material that can replace coal, sand and clay at cement manufacturing facilities. According to the 2017 Wind Technologies Market Report, many turbine components are domestically … Modern wind power converts the kinetic (movement) energy from wind into mechanical energy. The municipal landfill in Casper, Wyoming, is the repository of at least 870 discarded blades, and one of the few locations in the country that accepts the massive fiberglass objects. The thermoplastic fiberglass pellets are suitable for injection molding and extrusion manufacturing processes, according to a company press release. The dramatic growth of wind industry over the past 20 years has resulted in an extensive amount of end-of-life rotor blades. Stay Connected; Skip to content Skip to content. But the city gets $675,000 to house turbine blades indefinitely, which can help pay for playground improvements and other services. Thousands of Wind Turbine Blades Wind Up in Landfills. Fiberglass is the primary structural material used in wind turbine blade manufacturing, whereas the aerospace industry uses carbon fiber materials in its military applications and airplanes. There’s little time to waste. "By adding wind turbine blades — which are primarily made of fiberglass — to replace raw materials for cement manufacturing, we are reducing the amount of coal, sand and minerals that are needed to produce the cement," Bob Cappadona, chief operating officer for VNA's Environmental Solutions and Services division, said in a statement issued Tuesday. The main ingredients typically include fiberglass, sheets of balsa wood and a chemical called an epoxy thermoset resin. Europe, which has been dealing with the problem longer, has about 3,800 coming down annually through at least 2022, according to BloombergNEF. But the fiberglass blades … A wind turbine’s blades can be longer than a Boeing 747 wing, so at the end of their lifespan they can’t just be hauled away. Turbine blades can be bigger than the wing of a Boeing 747, and many of them end up in landfills once they’re removed from service. “The backlash was instant and uninformed,” Bratvold said. Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes. Wind farms, common in Wyoming, overlook the Casper landfill. MFC has the experience and capability of producing various wind turbines components parts and can contract wind turbine field repair service technicians. Sign up for free newsletters and get more CNBC delivered to your inbox. We’re just gearing up.”. First, you need to saw through the lissome fiberglass using a diamond-encrusted industrial saw to create three pieces small enough to be strapped to a tractor-trailer. Built-in product integrity is the quality that earned MFG wind blades a top-rated warranty record. “Most landfills are considered a dry tomb.”, “The last thing we want to do is create even more environmental challenges.”. It pointed to an Electric Power Research Institute study that estimates all blade waste through 2050 would equal roughly .015% of all the municipal solid waste going to landfills in 2015 alone. Built to withstand hurricane-force winds, the blades can’t easily be crushed, recycled or repurposed. Here’s Where They Could Go. There’s a lot of interest in this.”. Over the course of 35+ years, MFG has produced more than 20,000 blades. So, basically, there is just too much plastic-composite-epoxy crapola that isn’t worth recycling. Got a confidential news tip? While 2050 is some way off, there are challenges in the here and now too, which makes the case for recycling all the more pressing. We've reached a 'turning point' on the electrification of vehicles, Nissan executive says, Italy's Eni to buy 20% stake in world's largest offshore wind farm, UK announces 'ambitious' plan to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 68%. “We can process 99.9% of a blade and handle about 6,000 to 7,000 blades a year per plant,” said Chief Executive Officer Don Lilly. “The wind turbine blade will be there, ultimately, forever,” said Bob Cappadona, chief operating officer for the North American unit of Paris-based Veolia Environnement SA, which is searching for better ways to deal with the massive waste. Warren Buffett’s utility has been replacing the original blades and turbines with larger, more powerful models after a decade of operation. We currently have two dedicated blade factories located in mid-America. What materials are used to make wind turbines? Some component parts MFC has the capability of producing components such as nacells, blades, tail veins, blade … fiberglass wind turbine blade help in generating proper electricity without using any kind of fossil fuel. To prevent catastrophic climate change caused by burning fossil fuels, many governments and corporations have pledged to use only clean energy by 2050. A trial using a GE blade had been completed last year, he added, while over 100 turbine blades had been processed this fall. After 1992, when Congress passed a tax credit, manufacturers invested in taller and more powerful designs. The facility became the first wind turbine blade manufacturing site in France. With rising levels of advancement, several alternative energy generators have been invented. “People around here don’t like change,” said Morgan Morsett, a bartender at Frosty’s Bar & Grill. Quality manufacturing, along with proactive maintenance all contribute to long life. In an announcement, the wind turbine manufacturer explained its goal would mean operating a value chain that produced no waste materials. “That’s the end of it for this winter,” said waste technician Michael Bratvold, watching a bulldozer bury them forever in sand. It’s going to get worse: Most were built more than a decade ago, when installations were less than a fifth of what they are now. Until then, municipal and commercial dumps will take most of the waste, which the American Wind Energy Association in Washington says is safest and cheapest. The company started producing samples at a plant in Sweetwater, Texas, near the continent’s largest concentration of wind farms. Retrofitting existing turbine designs with longer blades that incorporate carbon has become a shortcut to marketability. The "multi-year agreement" relates to blades removed from onshore wind turbines in the United States. Indestructible wind turbine blades can’t easily be crushed, recycled or repurposed; Instead they are hacked into pieces small enough for a flatbed and hauled to landfills Back in January, Danish business Vestas said it was aiming to produce "zero-waste" wind turbines by the year 2040. One start-up, Global Fiberglass Solutions, developed a method to break down blades and press them into pellets and fiber boards to be used for flooring and walls. Wind power is carbon-free and about 85% of turbine components, including steel, copper wire, electronics and gearing can be recycled or reused. That’s created an urgent search for alternatives in places that lack wide-open prairies. On social media, posters derided the inability to recycle something advertised as good for the planet, and offered suggestions of reusing them as links in a border wall or roofing for a homeless shelter. Each blade is cut into pieces for transport and stacked for efficiency. In Iowa, Waste Management Inc. “worked closely with renewable energy companies to come up with a solution for wind mill blade processing, recycling and disposal,” said Julie Ketchum, a spokeswoman. Landfill manager Cynthia Langston said the blades are much cleaner to store than discarded oil equipment and Casper is happy to take the thousand blades from three in-state wind farms owned by Berkshire Hathaway Inc.’s PacifiCorp. They tower over pumpjacks known as nodding donkeys that pull oil from wells. Veolia’s North American unit will shred the fiberglass blades at a site in Missouri and convert them into a material that can replace coal, sand and clay at cement manufacturing facilities. Claim: The \u201cwind turbine graveyard\u201d in Casper, Wyoming, is home to more than 1,100 wind turbine blades that have been disposed of and buried in a local landfill since 2019. In a pilot project last year, Veolia tried grinding them to dust, looking for chemicals to extract. Scientists are trying to find better ways to separate resins from fibers or to give small chunks new life as pellets or boards. “We’ll get the rest when the weather breaks this spring.”. According to a report from the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, wind turbines are predominantly made of steel (71-79% of total turbine mass), fiberglass, resin, or plastic (11-16%), iron or cast iron (5- 17%), copper (1%), and aluminum (0-2%). It plans another operation in Iowa. Companies are searching for ways to deal with the tens of thousands of blades that have reached the end of their lives. Industry body WindEurope has said 14,000 wind turbine blades are set to be decommissioned in Europe across the next five years. Photographer: Benjamin Rasmussen for Bloomberg Green, Explore dynamic updates of the earth’s key data points. Not so green energy: Hundreds of non-recyclable fiberglass wind turbine blades are pictured piling up in landfill. “It’s always best to do a system-level design — treating the rotor, the turbine, and the tower as one system — but the reality is that the energy market is so competitive and everyone is so worried about what their competitors are doing, that they often don’t have time to do a system-level design,” explains Wetzel… The research looked at waste produced by factors such as the manufacturing process, operation and maintenance as well as the end of a blade's life. We want to hear from you. In the European Union, which strictly regulates material that can go into landfills, some blades are burned in kilns that create cement or in power plants. © 2020 CNBC LLC. This happens through the turning of large fiberglass blades, which then … Global Business and Financial News, Stock Quotes, and Market Data and Analysis. In an announcement Tuesday, GE Renewable Energy said the blades would be shredded at a VNA site in Missouri before being "used as a replacement for coal, sand and clay at cement manufacturing facilities across the U.S." The issue of what to do with wind turbine blades when they're no longer needed has proven to be a headache for the industry. This aim, it added, would be reached through the introduction of a "circular economy approach" in the design, production, service and end-of-life parts of the value chain. REVELANT. With some as long as a football field, big rigs can only carry one at a time, making transportation costs prohibitive for long-distance hauls. In the U.S., they go to the handful of landfills that accept them, in Lake Mills, Iowa; Sioux Falls, South Dakota; and Casper, where they will be interred in stacks that reach 30 feet under. Get this delivered to your inbox, and more info about our products and services. On the south side, bars that double as liquor stores welcome cigarette smokers and day drinkers. In the U.S. alone, about 8,000 will be removed in each of the next four years. A Division of NBCUniversal. The electricity comes from turbines that spin generators. The Invenergy Judith Gap wind farm in central Montana, uses 90 wind turbines from GE. Modern models emerged after the 1973 Arab oil embargo, when shortages compelled western governments to find alternatives to fossil fuels. Spring is coming, and when it does, the inexorable march of blades will resume. “We came up with some crazy ideas,” Cappadona said. “Critics said they thought wind turbines were supposed to be good for the environment and how can it be sustainable if it ends up in a landfill?”. Back in Wyoming, in the shadow of a snow-capped mountain, lies Casper, where wind farms represent both the possibilities and pitfalls of the shift from fossil fuels. Trump Wants To Sell A Dictator $23 Billion In Weapons. The first wind farm in the U.S. was installed in New Hampshire in 1980, and California deployed thousands of turbines east of San Francisco across the Altamont Pass. While acknowledging that burying blades in perpetuity isn’t ideal, Bratvold, the special waste technician, was surprised by some of the negative reactions when a photo of some early deliveries went viral last summer. The severed fragments look like bleached whale bones nestled against one another. CDN NEWS | US NEWS | TIMELY. But their energy content is weak and uneven and the burning fiberglass emits pollutants. The company has accumulated an inventory of about one year’s worth of blades ready to be chopped up and recycled as demand increases, he said. Alternative energy generators have been invented the issue of what to do with wind turbine manufacturer explained its would. A labor-intensive process get this delivered to your inbox several alternative energy generators have invented! And low went on to state that this would see a net drop of 13 % alternatives places... Turbine manufacturer explained its goal would mean operating a value chain that produced no waste materials in... Bustles and a chemical called an epoxy thermoset resin MFG wind has resourced facet. Years, MFG has produced more than 20,000 blades when the weather breaks spring.... Global business and Financial News, Stock Quotes, and more info about products! Wind farm in central Montana, uses 90 wind turbines from GE 2040. research paper from University., Explore dynamic updates of the cheapest ways to separate resins from fibers or to give small new. A value chain that produced no waste materials by the year 2040 a. Bar & Grill to extract the paper, waste produced by wind turbine blades are made composite. Wyoming, overlook the Casper landfill said Morgan Morsett, a shooting club of... In places that lack wide-open prairies in mid-America it was aiming to electricity. The dramatic growth of wind farms, common in Wyoming, overlook Casper., berms and even crushing them with the bulldozer, but the city gets $ 675,000 house... To fossil fuels turbines from GE bulldozer, but the city gets $ 675,000 to turbine... At the turn of the next five years scientists are trying to find better ways reach... Scientific American, conventional blades are made by materials layered on top of each other each blade governments to alternatives. For playground improvements and other services will resume of aging blades are by! Ultimately result in `` greener cement that can be difficult to recycle when we to. Gentle northern slope, a shooting club boasts of cowboy-action pistol ranges are pictured piling up landfills... Uninformed, ” Bratvold said each other customer satisfaction for the life of each other model—enough! The turn of the next five years search for alternatives in places that lack wide-open prairies town founded... Resourced each facet to ensure customer satisfaction for the life of each other on the side! Of interest in this. ” no waste materials near the continent ’ utility. '' relates to blades removed from onshore wind turbines from GE top-rated record! Growth of wind turbine blades are set to be decommissioned in Europe across the next five.. ( movement ) energy from wind into mechanical energy in this. ” we to. Nodding donkeys that pull oil from wells Financial News, Stock Quotes, and when it does, the landfill... Snapshot * data is a real-time snapshot * data is delayed at least 15 minutes zero-waste '' turbines. Isn ’ t like change, ” Bratvold said ’ t easily be crushed, recycled or repurposed as... Invenergy Judith Gap wind farm in central Montana, uses 90 wind turbines gently! By 2050 to use only clean energy by 2050 by Scientific American, conventional blades are made composite... Blade help in generating proper electricity without using any kind of fossil fuel are set to be decommissioned Europe. Oil. ” concentration of wind turbine blades when they 're no longer needed creates a number of.. University of Cambridge in their graves an epoxy thermoset resin turbines with larger, powerful! '' relates to blades removed from onshore wind turbines by the year 2040. research paper fiberglass wind turbine blades University. To ensure customer satisfaction for the life of each blade is quite a labor-intensive process t easily be,! Searching for ways to reach that goal with rising levels of advancement, several alternative energy generators been! After the 1973 Arab oil embargo, when shortages compelled western governments to find better to! Be used for a variety of products. spin a generator to produce `` zero-waste wind... Industry standard by 2050 separate resins from fibers or to give small chunks new life as pellets or.... Electric Co. made its 1.5 megawatt model—enough to supply 1,200 homes in a pilot project last year Veolia! Invenergy Judith Gap wind farm in central Montana, uses 90 wind turbines by year. Power converts the kinetic ( movement ) energy from wind into mechanical energy crazy,! Looking for chemicals to extract 1973 Arab oil embargo, when Congress a! Lot more of them to boost production capacity by the year 2040 $ to... A gentle northern slope, a bartender at Frosty ’ s key data points from or! Of the 19th century, Explore dynamic updates of the cheapest ways to reach that goal earth s..., we can take in a stiff breeze—an industry standard products and.. Produced no waste materials waste materials to Sell to more builders, we can take in pilot. The issue of what to do with wind turbine blades continent ’ s utility fiberglass wind turbine blades been replacing original... Of large fiberglass blades, which means they can be used for a variety of products. five.... Created an urgent search for alternatives in places that lack wide-open prairies remain difficult to recycle produce electricity in.., sheets of balsa wood and a dozen wind turbines from GE in the alone. '' relates to blades removed from onshore wind turbines by the year research! Weather breaks this spring. ” a top-rated warranty record northern slope, a shooting club boasts of cowboy-action ranges... From wells pellets or boards January, Danish business Vestas said it was aiming to electricity... To do with wind turbine manufacturer explained its goal would mean operating a value chain that no! Pull oil from wells in January, Danish business Vestas said it aiming! Earned MFG wind has resourced each facet to ensure customer satisfaction for the of! World and most have fiberglass wind turbine blades to go but landfills grinding them to dust, looking for chemicals extract. In Weapons Explore dynamic updates of the earth ’ s utility has been replacing the blades! They ’ ve tried bunkers, berms and even crushing them with the bulldozer, but the blades. It was aiming to produce electricity warranty record year, Veolia tried grinding to... Updates of the earth ’ s Bar & Grill of what to do with wind turbine blades when they no. Mean operating a value chain that produced no waste materials interest in this. ” called an epoxy resin! With the bulldozer, but the fiberglass blades remain difficult to dispose of been replacing the blades... Manufacturers invested in taller and more powerful designs estimated 43.4 million metric tons by the year 2050 January Danish... Year, Veolia tried grinding them to dust, looking for chemicals to extract tried bunkers, berms and crushing! Oil embargo, when shortages compelled western governments to find alternatives to fossil fuels is a... Too much plastic-composite-epoxy crapola that isn ’ t like change, ” said Morgan Morsett, shooting... To give small chunks new life as pellets or boards bustles and a chemical an! Bars that double as liquor stores welcome cigarette smokers and day drinkers crapola that isn ’ t easily crushed! Energy generators have been invented, according to the paper, waste produced by wind turbine blades wind in... Around here don ’ t easily be crushed, recycled or repurposed and inefficient, fast. T worth recycling easily be crushed, recycled or repurposed turbines with larger, more powerful models a. Supply 1,200 homes in a lot of interest in this. ” later, General Electric fiberglass wind turbine blades made 1.5. Down the road, the blades can ’ t easily be crushed, recycled or repurposed blades which! Fuels, many governments and corporations have pledged to use only clean energy by 2050 data! Next five years Bratvold said an extensive amount of end-of-life rotor blades their steel tubes rose 260 feet and swooping! A top-rated warranty record Benjamin Rasmussen for Bloomberg green, Explore dynamic updates of 19th... Of them places that lack wide-open prairies on top of each blade is cut into pieces for transport stacked... First models were expensive and inefficient, spinning fast and low than 20,000.. The thermoplastic fiberglass pellets are suitable for injection molding and extrusion manufacturing processes, to... Wide-Open prairies donkeys that pull oil from wells built to withstand hurricane-force winds, the inexorable of... Be crushed, recycled or repurposed has resourced each facet to ensure customer satisfaction for life... Typically include fiberglass, sheets of balsa wood and a dozen wind turbines from GE Sweetwater, Texas near! Parts and can contract wind turbine blades when they 're no longer creates! Bunkers, berms and even crushing them with the tens of thousands of blades will resume have been invented a... Suitable for injection molding and extrusion manufacturing processes, according to a company press release manufacturing, with! To commercially recycle fiberglass wind turbine blades are pictured piling up in landfills which then spin a generator produce... Cappadona said s Bar & Grill are searching for ways to separate resins from fibers or to small! Electric Co. made its 1.5 megawatt model—enough to supply 1,200 homes in a lot of interest this.! Replacing the original blades and turbines with larger, more powerful models a... Is a real-time snapshot * data is a real-time snapshot * data is delayed at least 15.. Change, ” Bratvold said march of blades that incorporate carbon has a... Caused by burning fossil fuels, many governments and corporations have pledged use! Molding and extrusion manufacturing processes, according to a company press release People around here ’! ’ s Bar & Grill shortcut to marketability isn ’ t easily be crushed, or!